May 1967, and much had changed since Brian Poole and The Tremeloes were at number 1 with Do You Love Me? four years previous. Beatlemania had just begun, and with Poole and co toppling the mighty She Loves You, the future bode well for the beat group from Dagenham. However, they simply couldn’t compete with the Fab Four, and as fashions changed, their fortunes were mixed. In 1964 they had two top 10 hits with covers of Roy Orbison’s Candy Man and The Crickets’ Someone Someone, but sales dropped the following year for I Want Candy and Good Lovin.
In 1966, singer Brian Poole left the group to try out a solo career. This didn’t work out, and he went on to form a label called Outlook Records. By the 70s he was working in his brother’s butchers. He would later have career in cabaret though, and his daughters Karen and Shelly made it to the charts in 1996 as Alisha’s Attic.
In addition to Poole’s departure, bassist Alan Howard left, so only rhythm guitarist and keyboardist Alan Blakley and drummer Dave Munden remained from the original line-up. They regrouped as a four-piece with new bass player Len ‘Chip’ Hawkes (father of 90s one-hit wonder Chesney Hawkes), and were now known as simply The Tremeloes. Making a conscious decision to cover more ‘hip’ material, their first two singles were versions of Paul Simon’s Blessed and The Beatles’ Good Day Sunshine. Neither charted, but a cover of Cat Stevens’ Here Comes My Baby reached number six.
For reasons unknown, they decided to follow this with Silence Is Golden. Previously a B-side for The Four Seasons, it had been written by their producer Bob Crewe and group member Bob Gaudio, the duo responsible for The Sun Ain’t Gonna Shine Anymore. The Tremeloes version closely followed the sound and arrangement of the original, with the band apeing The Four Seasons’ distinctive harmonies.
It had been three years since the original version of Silence Is Golden, and tastes had changed, so what were The Tremeloes thinking? Actually, scratch that, what were the British public thinking to take it to number 1 and make me look stupid?
It’s not that it’s a terrible song (although certainly no classic like The Sun Ain’t Gonna Shine Anymore), it’s just an unusual chart-topper as tastes had changed since 1964 and we’re here at the start of the Summer of Love, such an exciting time for music, and somehow, this single was at number 1 for five whole weeks.
What makes it worse is the lyrics suggest the singer is feeling sorry for themselves because a girl they care for is being mistreated by their lover, and they daren’t do anything about it, so ‘Silence is golden, but my eyes still see’. Well, forgive me for not thinking you should have a word with yourself and do something about the situation… A rather mediocre number 1, and the harmonies make me slightly nauseous.
The rest of the 60s were a mixed bag for The Tremeloes, with singles failures like Bob Dylan’s I Shall Be Released in 1968, and big hits such as (Call Me) Number One in 1969, which ironically went to number two.
In 1970 they were set to release a song called Yellow River by Jeff Christie as their follow-up. However when they changed their minds, producer Mike Smith removed their vocals and replaced them with Christie’s lead. It was a number 1 that June, while The Tremeloes’ By the Way bombed.
From 1972 onwards the group went through several line-up changes, with Munden the only constant throughout. Hawkes left to record solo albums but returned in 1979. In 1983 the original quartet reformed briefly. Hawkes left again in 1988 to manage his son, whose The One and Only was a big number 1 in 1991. To celebrate the 40th anniversary of the band, Brian Poole, Chip Hawkes and The Tremeloes toured together in 2006. Poole briefly appeared with them again in 2019, before retiring from touring.
Written by: Bob Crewe & Bob Gaudio
Producer: Mike Smith
Weeks at number 1: 5 (18 May-7 June)
Politician Graham Brady – 20 May
Footballer Paul Gascoigne – 27 May
Oasis singer-songwriter Noel Gallagher – 29 May
Poet John Masefield – 12 May
Children’s presenter Derek McCulloch – 1 June
Author Arthur Ransome – 3 June
20 May: Tottenham Hotspur defeated Chelsea 2-1 in the first all-London FA Cup final at Wembley Stadium.
25 May: Celtic FC became the first British and Northern European team to reach a European Cup final and also to win it, beating Inter Milan 2-1.
That same day, Conservative MP Enoch Powell attacked the Labour government, calling Britain the ‘sick man of Europe’.
28 May: Sir Francis Chichester arrived in Plymouth after completing a single-handed sailing voyage around the world in his yacht Gipsy Moth IV. It had taken him nine months and one day.
29 May: The first Spring Bank Holiday occurred on the last Monday of the month, replacing the former Whitsun holiday in England and Wales.
The Tulip Bulb Auction Hall hosted music festival Barbeque 67, featuring up-and-coming rock acts The Jimi Hendrix Experience, Cream and Pink Floyd.
1 June: The release of The Beatles’ landmark album Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, as well as the eponymous debut of a singer called David Bowie.
4 June: The Stockport Air Disaster was all over the papers when British Midland flight G-ALHG crashed in Hopes Carr, Stockport, killing 72 people.